P.J. Clarke’s Lincoln Square

44 W 63rd St., New York, NY 10023, USA

About P.J. Clarke’s Lincoln Square

4.2 / 5

from reviews

    Jakob W. Plummer
    -
    May 25, 2024

    Easiest place to go if seeing a show over at Lincoln Center. Lots of space - a basement level with equal service (bartenders down there are excellent) and it’s fast. Can be pricey. They oysters, at least, were $4 a pop. Oy! They make excellent drinks.

    Christopher
    -
    May 05, 2024

    Stopped here to eat a few weeks ago before going to see Shen Yun. We ordered our food including Calamari for an appetizer & side of onion rings. Our food came out but we never got the Calamari or the onion rings. A new waiter came over & we told him we never received the other items. He apologized & checked our order & it was never put in by the previous waitress, who was now off, since they were in between shift changes. We told him it was okay but we now didn’t want it. A few minutes later the GM Kairsten Nunn came over with our onion rings & said the calamari was also coming out. She apologized gave us the items on the house & was extremely professional. She even came back again to check on us to make sure we were ok & gave use her card for a free app on our return visit.The food was also great. Great food & great service. Thank you Kairsten. We will definitely be back again.

    Bonita Mita
    -
    December 29, 2023

    30min wait for a table which was not bad for a busy day. The space was a tad crowded. Our waitress was nice but everything took a very long time, taking the orders and bringing the food and drinks. The food is very good. My husband realized his glass was cracked all the way down and he Informed the waitress and normally at a good restaurant the entire drink would be exchanged, here the drink was transferred, so watered downed and maneuvered which was not expected of a good restaurant, expected better service and protocols for that scenario.

    Juan J. Moreno
    -
    October 21, 2023

    Very nice restaurant, hyper friendly service, and a good menu. There are several raw dishes, including a nice variety of oysters. Price are normal for a NY restaurant (expensive, but no more than others). I enjoyed a really good meal here, with a Clarke's Burger. It's been a while since I tasted the pure meat and simple ingredients that made hamburgers famous. No bacon, cheese, caramelized onions. Just the basics. And the cheesecake ... A real New York one! It was a great experience, recommended.

    Freddie B TV
    -
    December 23, 2023

    Really a 2.5 but the atmosphere is cool enough so we'll round up. Place is just "ok." My service was fine. Food was less stellar. Like so many other reviews have mentioned, it not much for the price. Don't expect to get a sizable portion at all. I'm sure there is a "Lincoln Square" surcharge here because the prices just don't add up. The chicken pot pie (pictured) is rather basic. Mine was hot and not just warm tho. It was smallish and taste wise, it was... Fine. The scallops was ordered by someone else at the table and that was a little better but quiet underwhelming as far as amount and still just fine on the taste-o-meter. Somebody else had the BBQ burger with fries. Fries weren't bad tho. This IS NOT a place you come out the way to. You just might even consider passing this place up leaving out of a show at Lincoln Square to be honest. But if you came, you won't be impressed and probably not let down but there is a possibility you could be.

    P.J. Clarke’s Lincoln Square

    Our Address

    44 W 63rd St., New York, NY 10023, USA

    A $49 Premium Listing Brings Local Customer Exposure To Your Business