Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Upper West Side

2450 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, USA

About Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Upper West Side

4.4 / 5

from reviews

    Sonii B
    -
    April 11, 2024

    We visited Carmine’s Upper West Side for my daughter’s birthday. It’s definitely perfect for a special occasion or group experience. It’s family style so the servings are abundant. You can definitely feed at least three adults with certain dishes. The service was excellent and we arrived at a good time… around 4:30ish before the dinner rush started showing up. I highly recommend reservations. The first person we were assigned was a super kind Ghanaian guy (didn’t catch his name). I was a little sad when he said he was leaving and turned us over to Scott. Scott ended up being superbly attentive, professional and helpful. Our food arrived relatively quickly and we were checked on often enough. He didn’t rush us and helped sing happy birthday, The atmosphere is definitely old school Manhattan, Italian style…. Very vintage yet well maintained. The music was a little loud at times but the vibe was pleasant. Everyone we interacted with was kind and courteous. Bring a big appetite.

    Richard Rally
    -
    November 11, 2023

    This was one of the best Italian food places I've ever dined at. The portions are amazingly big! The Vodka Sauce Pasta dish was delicious! The salad was tasty and fresh! The variety of included bread was mouth watering. The service was pretty good. I enjoyed my dining experience here and the location was perfect before seeing our Broadway show.

    Mark LoGiurato
    -
    January 28, 2024

    Famous for its generous family-style portions. All the food is cooked to order and delicious. The salads, antipasto, and pastas are all made fresh. The restaurant caters to large parties with plenty of space in the main dining room. The bar is also a good place for dining.

    Kim Burgess
    -
    May 10, 2024

    Yesterday I decided to get takeout from Carmines and when I got home the food was horrible. The wings were burnt. The parmigiana chicken was hard and dry. There was barely any sauce on the chicken and pasta. For the amount of money they charge you would think the food would be great. I decided to give it another try on the take out because I only ordered 2 items. Then my beverages were missing so I asked the woman for them and she came from behind the counter to check the receipt and search the bag like I was lying which was kind of weird because she handed me the bag which was opened and you can clearly see what’s inside. If you’ve ordered takeout from this location then you would know how close she was that she didn’t need to do all of that. It was my kids idea to get Italian food so I did what mothers do. But, Carmines this is so disappointing to have another horrible experience with the take out. It seems like restaurants just give you anything when you order takeout because they know you’re not gonna return it. I spent over $100 for this. Ridiculous

    irene rivera rodriguez
    -
    December 19, 2023

    We made reservations & were still seated 15 after our reservations. The crowd was lively & out right loud. The service was excellent. The wait staff was attentive & friendly. The food is served family style, so we had food to take home. The food was delicious as always.

    Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Upper West Side

    Our Address

    2450 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, USA

    A $49 Premium Listing Brings Local Customer Exposure To Your Business